Limited company

Goodwill on Incorporation: How to Value It and What HMRC Expects

How to value goodwill when a sole trader incorporates, how Incorporation Relief and Business Asset Disposal Relief apply in 2026/27, and what HMRC expects to see.

Blue Tick Accountants guide: Goodwill on Incorporation: How to Value It and What HMRC Expects

Goodwill on incorporation is valued at what an independent buyer would pay for your business's reputation and customer base, and HMRC expects that value to be supported by evidence rather than chosen to suit your tax position. For any incorporation from sole trader to limited company in the UK, the figure affects your capital gains tax, your director's loan account and the company's balance sheet. Blue Tick Accountants, a Guildford-based UK tax advisory and accountancy practice, sees goodwill valued too low out of caution, or too high to create a large loan balance, and both approaches create problems.

This guide explains what goodwill is, how to value it, how Incorporation Relief and Business Asset Disposal Relief interact with it, and why the company usually gets no corporation tax deduction for it. A worked example for 2026/27 shows the numbers.

Key Takeaways

  • Goodwill transferred from a sole trader to their own company is treated as sold at market value for capital gains tax, whatever price is actually paid.
  • Incorporation Relief under section 162 of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992 applies automatically when a business is transferred as a going concern with all its assets, other than cash, in exchange for shares.
  • Without Incorporation Relief, a gain on goodwill can qualify for Business Asset Disposal Relief at 18% in 2026/27, with a £3,000 annual exempt amount available against it.
  • A company that buys goodwill from a connected sole trader normally receives no corporation tax deduction for it, even though it is shown as an asset in the accounts.
  • Corporation tax for 2026/27 is 19% on profits up to £50,000 and 25% above £250,000, with an effective marginal rate of 26.5% in between.
  • Paying for goodwill with a director's loan lets you withdraw the balance tax-free later, but it reduces Incorporation Relief.

What is goodwill and why does it matter on incorporation?

Goodwill is the value of a business over and above its tangible assets, arising from its reputation, customer relationships, location and ongoing profits. When a sole trader moves the business into a new limited company, goodwill is usually the most valuable asset being transferred.

The company is a separate legal person, so a transfer of the business to it is a disposal for tax. Because sole trader and company are connected, section 17 of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992 treats the disposal as made at market value, not at the price you actually agree. That is why goodwill must be valued even where no cash changes hands.

The goodwill figure therefore matters in three places: the gain on your personal tax return, the opening balance sheet of the company, and the size of any amount the company owes you afterwards. Getting the figure wrong in any of those places can lead to a tax enquiry and a corrected return. Our guide to moving from sole trader to limited company shows where valuation fits in the wider process.

How do you value goodwill when incorporating a sole trader business?

You value goodwill by estimating the price an arm's length buyer would pay for the business, and the usual method is a multiple of maintainable annual profit. HMRC publishes no fixed formula, and its Shares and Assets Valuation team negotiates on the facts of each case, so the supporting evidence matters more than the multiple itself.

A typical valuation starts with average profits over the last two or three years, adjusted for one-off items and for a realistic salary for the owner's own work. A multiple reflecting the sector, how dependent the business is on you personally, contract renewal rates and growth is then applied. A one-person consultancy whose clients follow the owner will generally support a lower multiple than a business with a trained team and recurring contracts.

Keep a short written valuation note showing the profit figures, the multiple, the comparable evidence and the reasoning. If HMRC queries the return, that note is the first thing requested. A professional valuation is worthwhile for higher figures, and an adviser can usually agree a defensible range before the transfer takes place.

Does Incorporation Relief remove the tax on goodwill?

Incorporation Relief defers the capital gains tax on goodwill by deducting the gain from the base cost of the shares you receive. It applies automatically if you transfer the business as a going concern, together with all its assets other than cash, wholly or partly in exchange for shares.

Deferral is not exemption. The gain is held in the shares and becomes taxable when you sell them, or if the company later sells the goodwill. That makes it attractive when you plan to hold the company for a long time.

If you also take cash or a loan credit as part of the price, the relief is restricted in proportion to the non-share consideration. You can elect for the relief not to apply, within a time limit, and some owners choose that route to use Business Asset Disposal Relief, which is 18% in 2026/27 on gains up to a £1,000,000 lifetime limit. That decision needs modelling before the transfer, not after.

What is a worked example of goodwill on incorporation?

A worked example shows how the choice between relief and election changes the numbers. Take Sam, a sole trader who incorporates in 2026/27 with goodwill valued at £80,000 and no other chargeable assets.

Route one is Incorporation Relief. Sam receives shares worth £80,000 and the £80,000 gain is deferred. No tax is due now, and the shares have a base cost of nil. If Sam later sold the shares for £80,000, the gain would be £80,000 at that point.

Route two is to elect out and take a £80,000 director's loan credit instead. Sam's gain of £80,000 is reduced by the £3,000 annual exempt amount to £77,000. If the conditions for Business Asset Disposal Relief are met, tax is 18% of £77,000, which is £13,860. In exchange, Sam can withdraw £80,000 from the company over time as loan repayments, tax-free and without dividend tax at the 10.75% ordinary rate.

Neither route is right for everyone. Route one defers a tax bill, route two pays £13,860 now to create an £80,000 balance that can be extracted without further tax, provided the company has the cash. Our article on extracting profits from your limited company compares loan repayments with salary and dividends.

Can the company claim tax relief on goodwill after incorporation?

The company generally cannot claim a corporation tax deduction for goodwill bought from a connected sole trader. Since 2015, the rules in Part 8 of the Corporation Tax Act 2009 have denied amortisation relief on goodwill acquired from a related party, so the asset sits on the balance sheet without reducing taxable profit.

This is a common surprise because the accounts may show amortisation as an expense even though the tax computation adds it back. Any goodwill loan is therefore repaid out of profits that have already borne corporation tax at 19%, 25% or the 26.5% effective marginal rate in between, which makes the size of the goodwill figure worth weighing carefully. Our corporation tax guide for 2026/27 sets out the rates and marginal relief.

Other points on the transfer sit alongside goodwill. VAT can usually be passed across without charge if the business transfers as a going concern, and the new company must register if needed. There is no stamp duty on goodwill, and plant and machinery can be transferred at tax written down value if both parties elect. Our pillar on incorporating your business: the complete tax guide for sole traders covers each of these points.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is goodwill worth when I incorporate my sole trader business?

Goodwill is worth the price an independent buyer would pay, usually estimated as a multiple of the business's maintainable annual profit after a fair salary for the owner. HMRC sets no fixed multiple. The figure depends on sector, how reliant the business is on you personally, and recurring income, so keep a written valuation.

Do I pay capital gains tax on goodwill when I incorporate?

Not necessarily. Incorporation Relief defers the gain automatically when a going concern is transferred to a company in exchange for shares. If you take cash or a loan credit, the relief is restricted. Where relief does not apply, gains may qualify for Business Asset Disposal Relief at 18% in 2026/27.

Can my limited company claim tax relief on goodwill I sold to it?

Generally no. Goodwill acquired by a company from a connected sole trader attracts no corporation tax amortisation relief, because the rules in Part 8 of the Corporation Tax Act 2009 deny it. The goodwill can still appear as an asset in the accounts, but the tax computation adds back any amortisation.

Is VAT charged when I transfer my business to a limited company?

Usually not, if the business is transferred as a going concern and the company is, or must become, VAT registered. The transfer falls outside the scope of VAT as a transfer of a going concern. Conditions apply, so check them before the transfer date. The registration threshold for 2026/27 is £90,000.

What is the director's loan created by selling goodwill to my company?

It is a debt the company owes you equal to the unpaid price for goodwill. You can draw it back from the company without income tax or dividend tax, as long as the company has the cash. It also reduces Incorporation Relief, because the relief is restricted where non-share consideration is taken.

How Blue Tick Can Help

Blue Tick Accountants advises sole traders on the financial and tax case for incorporation, including goodwill valuation, Incorporation Relief elections, VAT transfer and the first year of company compliance. We model the options in pounds before you commit, so the decision rests on your numbers. Head to our website and book a meeting now.

Conclusion

Goodwill on incorporation is taxed at market value, so a defensible valuation is the foundation of the whole transfer. Incorporation Relief defers the gain, while an election and a loan credit can bring tax forward in exchange for flexible extraction later, and the company will get no corporation tax deduction either way. The most valuable action before you incorporate is to model both routes with a written valuation in hand, so the choice is made deliberately and not by default.

About the Author

This guide was written by Leon, founder of Blue Tick Accountants, a Guildford-based UK tax advisory and accountancy practice that helps landlords, limited company owners and the self-employed across the UK. It was last reviewed for the 2026/27 tax year.

This article is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute tax, legal, or financial advice. Tax rules are subject to change and their application will depend on your individual circumstances. You should always seek advice from a qualified professional before taking action. Blue Tick Accountants accepts no liability for decisions made on the basis of this content.

Related reading: VAT Transfer of Going Concern: What Incorporating Businesses Need to Know.

Need help with this? See our Limited Company Accountants page

Frequently asked questions

How much is goodwill worth when I incorporate my sole trader business?

Goodwill is worth the price an independent buyer would pay, usually estimated as a multiple of the business's maintainable annual profit after a fair salary for the owner. HMRC sets no fixed multiple. The figure depends on sector, how reliant the business is on you personally, and recurring income, so keep a written valuation.

Do I pay capital gains tax on goodwill when I incorporate?

Not necessarily. Incorporation Relief defers the gain automatically when a going concern is transferred to a company in exchange for shares. If you take cash or a loan credit, the relief is restricted. Where relief does not apply, gains may qualify for Business Asset Disposal Relief at 18% in 2026/27.

Can my limited company claim tax relief on goodwill I sold to it?

Generally no. Goodwill acquired by a company from a connected sole trader attracts no corporation tax amortisation relief, because the rules in Part 8 of the Corporation Tax Act 2009 deny it. The goodwill can still appear as an asset in the accounts, but the tax computation adds back any amortisation.

Is VAT charged when I transfer my business to a limited company?

Usually not, if the business is transferred as a going concern and the company is, or must become, VAT registered. The transfer falls outside the scope of VAT as a transfer of a going concern. Conditions apply, so check them before the transfer date. The registration threshold for 2026/27 is £90,000.

What is the director's loan created by selling goodwill to my company?

It is a debt the company owes you equal to the unpaid price for goodwill. You can draw it back from the company without income tax or dividend tax, as long as the company has the cash. It also reduces Incorporation Relief, because the relief is restricted where non-share consideration is taken.